I have reviewed my stats and all indicate that I should have the Star Seller badge based on the previous period (Sept-Nov).
Message Response Rate - 100%
On Time Shipping and Tracking - 100%
Average Review Rating - 5.0
Case Rate - 0
Orders - 9 (my shop was on vacation for much of the period, but I did achieve the minimum 5 orders)
Sales - $335.05
@TurnTurnWoodworking: "Sales - $335.05" Is that amount '... $300 before shipping and taxes ...' https://www.etsy.com/seller-handbook/article/1085067202187