You have to wait up to an hour for them to update but I agree, it's a shop feature and it should work. It somehow worked for years and now it takes forever to update.
I updated mine today. I wrote down start of titles of the ones I wanted to change to. Then went to quick edit and unstarred the old ones. Then using quick edit again, found the new ones to star. It takes about 30 minutes for it to update. At least it did for me. Hope this helps.
Has anyone noticed that this has been fixed? I just changed my featured items and they showed up immediately. I was shocked! I hope it stays fixed. And thanks to whoever is responsible for correcting the issue.
