Cristy, first let me say how well done your shop is - I love that your placement of the soap is so uniform, it's almost calming to know that with each turn of the page the soap will look the same, all I will have to do is look for the color and the title - it's very calm in what could be slightly chaotic with so many choices, but I felt totally at ease cruising around deciding amongst all the options.
As for Eye Catching, that was a QUICK find for me, let me tell you!
http://www.etsy.com/listing/118311737/spring-sale-triple-s-soap?ref=shop_home_activeWhat are the 3 S's for?!?! What would it smell like?!?! Can't get the window open fast enough!!! LOL. Not only did the vivid color combo catch me, but the title caught me too - perfection. And... smells like peach? If I had not hidden my wallet already, I would have purchased it on the spot. Love it!