Tonya - Thanks so much for your response and thanks too for complimenting my work! I looked at both your shops and your work is beautiful - love your style!
Since posting here, I have done a few sales, some lower priced pieces (less than $60) as well as a few $180-$400, so I am feeling much more confident now. The 3 lesser priced items I sold (horseshoe earrings) sold in less than 48 hours after I uploaded - the first pair sold before I'd even uploaded the next! Now that I have a bit more time, I'm going to make a whole bunch of those $30-$60 earrings and see what happens.
I also discovered that with the higher priced items, I had conversations with the buyers back and forth before they committed. They wanted to know exact sizes, dimensions, return policy, etc before spending that much money on something sight unseen, which I certainly understand! The nice thing is, one of the buyers of a more expensive piece ordered a custom piece from me right after her first piece arrived, and another customer is also discussing further purchases. My jewelry is a bit unusual - not for everyone - but I have found at brick and mortar stores as well as my own site that I have repeat customers quite frequently...My bread and butter.
Again thanks for the input - think you were spot on about doing some lower priced items.
Best wishes for continued success to you,
Vanessa