New features! Quality ranking and voting for treasuries!

[Former_Member]

I have added new features to treasurypromo.com

1) You can vote for last treasuries now.
Good - If You like it! :)
Bad - If You don't like it! :(
Voting is anonymous.

2) Depending on votes about treasuries, members have their quality ranking now.
You can see it in members list.

This will help us to make more better treasuries! ;)

[Solandia]

I have an idea to leave just the positive voting.
Or make it possible to give point - 1, 2 or 3 where 3 is the max.
This would be more in the spirit of Etsy.

It would be also more convenient after letting point to know till which place on the treasury list one has already voted. (I mean that the cursor should highlight or something like that so as not to search every time for the right positioning).

Also self estimating should be avoided.
What about this?

[Former_Member]

I agree with you :)

What other team members think about Savenna idea?
"....make it possible to give point - 1, 2 or 3 where 3 is the max..... "

[Former_Member]

Still not sure about the voting thing...

However, I agree with Savenna about the points.

I think you should include treasuries created up to 12 hours past not just one page because we are an international team and have different time zones. For example, I have just got up and seen treasuries created overnight for me. One of the beautiful ones created is down the bottom of the list so if I had got up an hour later it would be gone from the list and I couldn't vote on it.

Also, is there any way you can just show the treasury name not the entire link. Or show the entire link in a wider field so we can see the name? The reason is that if someone creates a lot of treasuries I have to click on them all to see which one is the one I was featured in.

Otherwise voting could take too much time and that is something most of us don't have!

Thanks for listening Janis :)

[Former_Member]

I agree with Savenna regarding points, and also with Andrea about the time frame elongation :)
Great ideas ladies!

[Solandia]

Yes, I observed same as Andrea - when I want to see a treasury and then I came back to the list I'm lost to where I've been up to.

Is there a way you make it turn back wher ewe stopped, not all the time at the top.
Or maybe put numbers infront treasuries?

[Former_Member]

I will think about it, Savenna.

[ixela]

Hi all... I was away two days from home and so had no time and no chances to make treasuries and so I saw just this morning the result of the new rules on the ranking in the Members Shops list (so not speaking at all about me and my shop!)... it seems that persons/shops who has worked a lot and made many and many treasuries are in the last places while persons/shops that has less treasuries are on the top... so the quality of the treasuries play a very important role in the ranking... but I suppose that many members forget now and will forget (or have no time) in the future to leave also a rewiev about quality of every treasury and so this score doesn't depict the real value of every treasury, so conditioning badly the ranking!
I suppose it could be better if it should be possible to appoint to every new treasury the maximum value and then give the possibility to every member to signal just mediocre or bad treasuries... something like a subtraction system.... I guess that just in these cases (that are not so much) everyone of us who see its own items in a mediocre or bad treasury has the real interest to vote / signal that specific treasury and not the countrary!... I hope you can understand me and my very bad english... so sorry for all my mistakes!!!

[Former_Member]

Maybe we can also make a request that after you post a treasury you look, click, and rate at least five other treasuries from the list? That way we can help promote each others treasuries.

[Former_Member]

I agree with Whitney

[MollysMuses]

Hi,
This team looks fun.
I created a T and submitted it, but when I look at the treasuries and the votes etc, mine doesn't show up, it doesn't show up when I click on YOUR either, should I resubmit it?

[Former_Member]

Yes, try again.

[MollysMuses]

I cant submit after 6 hours. I see my treasury where it goes in for karma points, but not where I can see it on the list what people gave for stars? Can we just not see our own maybe?

[Former_Member]

Can you paste it here and I will check it?

[MollysMuses]

sure;)
https://www.etsy.com/treasury/NzMzNTkzMHwyNzIyNTU1MTIx/wink-to-the-holidays
https://www.etsy.com/treasury/NzMzNTkzMHwyNzI1MTE4MzM2/early-winter-finds

[MollysMuses]

and this one doesnt show up to?
https://www.etsy.com/treasury/NzMzNTkzMHwyNzIyNTU4NDU5/personalize-and-customize
I see my name on member shops on the page also but no stars?

[paulamattson]

Janis, I wrote a detailed email, hope I will receive a response. I am concerned about the whole idea, very confused about the karma thing, points, charges, I really feel I would like to reconsider joining as I am not that smart about all this promo stuff. Please contact me. Paula

[Former_Member]

Molly, the bug is fixed and I submitted your treasuries ;)

[Former_Member]

I'm really not sure if this is a good idea... Why would people will vote down the treasuries? I mean like, some shops need to take better photographs, if the picture looks bad, of course the treasury will turn out bad, and why would I even wanted to place those bad photos on the first 2 lines? I'm not being rude just thinking out loud.

[LittleAppleNY]

I'm not sure I can keep up with this. I lost 18 points in less than a day and now find that there are very few qualified shops to choose from to earn points back. Am I missing something?

[Former_Member]

It is good that you loose your points , because If you lose your points it means that you are featured in treasuries.

[MaldonadoJewellery]

I agree with Demy .

And besides, I think it would be good to promote a better quality of the images of some stores. Perhaps they should vote for it.
These days I have noticed that:

* There are wonderful treasures that are unjustly qualified . Why ... ?

* We must be aware that by including team members , we are removing the member points . We therefore we should work to look great treasure . Otherwise, you will waste our time and that of the other members .

[Solandia]

@Janis, thanks for making it! :)

One more question - what do you think about taking off the evaluating system that gives points for using items in rows? Sometimes you just can't let an item where you primary decided to so as to fit right? What is the difference as far as the team items are used in the upper three rows?

Will it be proper to remove this rule and give equal point for all the 5 team members used as far as they ar ein the upper 3 rows?

[Former_Member]

Savenna, It is because:

1) when you look at treasuries, you see only the first line.
https://www.etsy.com/treasury/

2) when you look at front page, you see only the first three lines.

[Solandia]

Yes, Janis, I know. But when we have extra appealing shops in team we can do this with the first row.

@Dione, I have the same difficulty. Waiting till good shops appear so as o make a T. Beacuse yet making T's with all of teh same shops might become boring. And I'm a type to get bored fast.

But yet I think it is all very well done since people may learn a lot about what they are missing and to compare. Stimulating them to open treasuries an dto have a fast look at many Ts at ones is just a very good lesson.

Hope we will have more beautiful shops here.