TAGS!
Eliminate all one-word tags. Use 2-3 word phrases in both your title and your tags to show up in search. Separate your title phrases by commas
For example:
https://www.etsy.com/listing/151916457/white-feather-wings-real-angel-wings?ref=shop_home_active_22This listing (which is one of your better photos...maybe try switching the main photo to what you currently have as photo #2...LOVE it)
Instead of wings, angel, fairy, raven, fantasy
Use
fairy angel wings
white feather wings
Halloween wings
fair costume wings
And continue until you've used all the relevant search terms you think of.
Think like your customers! When you search for an item on etsy, how do you search it. You don't type in "red" YIKES! You'd get a bazillion search results.
Search your item. Type in wings. See how many search results there are. Then change your title and tags. Wait an hour. Go back and search the new 3 word term after you've made the changes and see how far up you've moved in the pages and pages of wings.