I met all the criteria for a star seller and some of the other badges last quarter yet my account still doesn't reflect the star seller badge or any of the other badges. They are all still showing locked. I would like to know why that is since I achieved all the goals last quarter.
Looks like you did not meet the $300 in sales.
Did you meet the minimum of 5 orders and $300 in sales (before shipping and taxes) within the three month review period?
Have you had an notifications for intellectual property theft?
I can see several items in your shop that would be illegal counterfeits unless you have obtained legal licensing from the IP holders.
They will permanently remove badges for breaking Etsy's Terms of Use.
Other than your question about missing the Star Seller badge, you are also missing policies, not showing your shop location on your cover page, and filling out more in your "about" section would be good for your shop. A banner would be good too, to make your shop look more complete.