When I sell one of my items, if there are multiple quantities, it gets relisted and automatically gets moved to the first spot on my first page. This is not currently working. I have checked my settings to make sure that nothing changed and it is still set correctly. It has been set this way for many years. Here is what it looks like under shop options (I have the option Disabled, marked).
You have set a custom order for your listings using Rearrange Your Shop.
Please ignore, it looks like it is working now....
Hi, I don't use the Rearrange Feature, but many do. Here is a recent Thread about this issue (same as yours). It's been a problem for a while now. See the post by ButterflyFeetDigital, and I hope it works for you.
https://community.etsy.com/t5/Technical-Issues/Shop-REARRANGE-Mode-NOT-WORKING/m-p/148457973
Please ignore, it looks like it is working now....