@BigXStudio: "Anyone else experiencing this?" Issues with eMail notifications is a recurring topic in these forums.
Presuming that the eMail was sent (and there is no real reason to think it was not if you have that option enabled), many bad things can happen after the eMail has left Etsy's eMail server. Your eMail provider or Internet Service Provider or even a relaying server could be blocking the eMail in error and it never even makes it to your eMail client much less your SPAM or junk folder.
Again presuming that the eMail was sent and depending on where in the process the eMail was blocked and who your eMail provider is, sometimes whitelisting the sending domain can help.
Also, at least some of Etsy's eMail servers appear to be misconfigured - some inbound eMail servers attempt to validate the eMail and we have seen (and it has been confirmed by others) that some of their servers sometimes report (incorrectly) that the sender is not valid. If an inbound server receives this 'not a valid sender' response they will most probably discard the eMail without the recipient being aware of its existence.
