For the October to December period, my dashboard has 3 100%. Why don't I have a star seller badge?
I don't see the "Speedy Replies" badge on your shop. Check and see if Etsy thinks you missed some messages. Check to be sure you are looking at the previous period and not the current period in your dashboard.
@LarkRoadRhymes - Have you also made the required number of sales(5), and the total item revenue ($300) needed?
Oops, just looked at shop...you probably have : )