I have a listing, https://www.etsy.com/listing/708297372, where Etsy has changed the materials.
The listing says that the materials are silver.
I entered, and my listing STILL says under edit, that the materials are: silver plated band bracelet, silver plated charm, silver plated lobster clasp closure.
I received a review where the buyer is saying that the item is not 925 sterling silver.
I contacted Etsy customer service and the rep, Kenny disconnected with me and refused to help me.
This is after 30 minutes.
So, I received a negative review and am being accused of selling fraudulent items because Etsy changed my materials.
I'm glad you were able connect with Etsy about this.
And thank you for posting because I found the thread very helpful. It never occurred to me that the attributes override the materials.
And I think the idea about including options (silver plated, etc.) is a really great one. Silver is also listed as a color - which is how I use it.
So all in all a good thread.
Please don't be upset. The forums generate free form discussion. Once you post you're likely to get helpful suggestions and a range of comments that may be broader than what you actually wanted.