Badges

[FoxesHandcrafts]

Message response rate 100% 
On time shipping 100%
All 5 star reviews

Only received Rave reviews badge.

[ChristmasIsLove]

If you're looking at the front graph, that's the next review period. Click on Last Review Period to see stats for the Dec 1 badges.

[BagmakerSupply]

@FoxesHandcrafts: A quick search of this forum would show you innumerable threads about your issue. Remember that the stats you now see are for the January star (October, November and December). The "Last Review Period" shows the stats for the December Star (September, October and November).