Hi all! I have learned to sell more on etsy, you really have to promote. A LOT. Join teams that do promotions. Make treasuries. Promote on facebook, pinterest and (my newest addition) twitter. Others help you promote that way.
Deborah-- I have done something similar. I have some supplies that I sell along with my jewelry. It's very similar items, so I just went with it. I asked a friend who has two shops- one for jewelry, one for supplies - why she did that and other info. She said she was combining them now (which she has done) since things somehow find a way to both shops anyway.