I never seem to have luck with it either! My daughter recently made bones out of it for her necklaces and earrings, and since we bake ours in a regular oven with the cookie sheet all sealed up with foil, we don't really get to see it until we uncover it. Well, her bones turned a nice shade of light beige, which surprised me as I'd forgotten to check the clock, and they were overcooked. My problem is I always overwork it, then end up with those nasty little floaties in it!