Trick Question...

[Former_Member]

So if you did not answer the question to be in this team here it is:

Which came first: the phoenix or the flame?

Im just wondering what other people say.

Thanks,
HL

[BrightByrdCreations]

I said, "They are one and the same."

[Former_Member]

Your answer I think means the same as my answer but i want to see if anyone has anything different before i give the answer away.

[Former_Member]

I said phoenix but agree with Fromhere2Daydreams.

[LasagnaTheCat]

I said A circle has no beginning ;)

[Former_Member]

I said, "It is a never ending cycle, with no beginning and no end." I'm probably wrong though, lol.

I'm dying to know what the answer is. :)

[GnomeGoods]

I said flame.... but now I am thinking I am wrong ;(

[Former_Member]

heheheh I said " A Circle Has No End" No Beginning for that matter either!!

[BeamMeUpMommy]

I've always thought that the flame came first. The flame came first to light the way. :D

[Former_Member]

A lot of you were right (LasagnaTheCat, FindingStarlight, and SunDoorBeads).
A circle has no Begining

[Former_Member]

I watch a little too much and read even more :P

[Former_Member]

Me too I read a lot I was going with titles and happenings and flame I asociated with goblet of fire duh

[Former_Member]

That is duh on me not u

[Former_Member]

I answered that neither has beginning or ending. I think that's close to what Luna said in book 7.

[Former_Member]

This is from book 7 when Harry and Luna try to get into Ravenclaw tower

Luna: "a circle has no beginning' the door-knocker complemented her on her reasoning