Hi Agnessa,
I have thought a lot about opening a second Etsy shop too...based on all that I keep reading about cohesiveness. But I've finally decided not to. I have a huge assortment of items...lots of different handmade items, vintage items, jewelry, quilts, fabric, supplies, etc. My shop is not cohesive & not very organized either. In fact, I haven't even rearranged my shop since Etsy changed to our new look a couple months ago. That's mainly because I don't know how to do it. Anyway, what I was getting at is that I get lots of views & plenty of sales & for me - that's what counts. I've found that the more listings you have, the more views & sales you get - so the last thing you want to do is reduce the items in your shop by 1/2.
♡ Jewel