Which photo to be the front?

[JewelMeShop]

I am not sure what to choose. The first photo is showing the item alone with a white background. The second one saws excactly what the item is. Which one is better for the item and you believe goes better with my shop?
https://www.etsy.com/listing/107366816/leather-bag-charm-purse-charm-zipper

[Former_Member]

I am drawn to the fifth photo you have, but I can see your issue. You don't want the buyer to think you are selling the bag. Hmmm, I do prefer the photo with the bag in it though.

Best of luck.

[BZFingers]

I'd keep it as it is. You never know how people would like to use your charm, with what kind of accessory, so it is better to show it as it is with the white background.
But I would add to the description the size of it, because it is not clear how big (long/wide) it is even if we look at the picture with the bag, because we don't know how big the bag is too :)
Good luck

[Former_Member]

To me the white background does something to the piece doesn't show it clearly. I like the fourth picture.

[JewelMeShop]

Natasha I also prefer the photo with the bag. My problem is that I try to make my shop as much cohesive as possible and white background helps this purpose.
BZfingers you're totally right. I should add the size in the description thanks for mentioning that!

[BZFingers]

Well, I looked one more time and still think that white background is preferred. You don't sell bags and black charm doesn't stay out on a black bag. Also image with the bag has very little chance to get into treasuries.
But I agree that current white background image not very clear. I would suggest to retake the picture - do not attach the charm to anything, just put it flat on the white surface so that nice locking carabiner also in the picture.
<3

[JewelMeShop]

Lauren and BZfingers you're both right. I should reshoot it with a white background or use a better photo editor.
I will try both.