Atta girl, Karly!
Your shop looks great! Super photos, lots of color, and your prices are very reasonable for all your items.
We all struggle with pricing, especially because we do what we love, but that doesn't mean we shouldn't be compensated for our time creating.
The general rule is, if you're not selling, don't reduce your prices, rather increase them... it's a perceived value thing, and as you now see, it works ;)