Hi Julie Lynn,
I agree with Alexis. I think for your main photo, you should just show one item clearly and then in the title line use words to say that it is for a whole collection. You could keep the photos you already have, but have them be the second photo, rather than the main photo. One aspect that is really great is that you have the Prints pictures scattered throughout....Those give the eye place to rest upon...though the pictures for the prints are a little faint....it's not easy to read what the saying is.
Also, I would mix up the colors. Right now it looks like you have all the turquoise together in a group and all the multicolor together in a group, etc.....I would rearrange your front page to display all the different color options at first glance.
Hope this helps a little - a great shop! Just a little too busy at first glance.
Best wishes,
Lisa