Yep, strange move from Etsy, as usual.
You can (finally) choose to not have your sold items seen. BUT now each review shows the entire sold item listing.... Brilliant! Not.
It serves no purpose. Other than annoying sellers, which Etsy seems to think is a good thing to do.
PS: I closed my shop, but want people to still be able to see what I used to sell. Yet I am happy for other sellers that they can finally turn that off.