Nothing really looked right for this item. I finally went with "Accessories" and then nothing after that. I just don't really have a good sense of what, if any, category would make sense. Thoughts?
That's probably what I would've done too. I see a lot of inspirational items under "Jewelry", but yours aren't really jewelry, so that won't work. "Accessories" seems to be a fairly good fit. Is there a category for "trinkets"? That might work too.
I looked up "pocket coins" in search. Some ppl put them under accessories and some under everything else - pocket. I think the latter makes more sense.