Thanks everyone!
Well, Cindy, I guess I nailed it with tags and titles! The first three words are weighted in the title section so I made sure that they most directly described the item in general terms (bandana bib). Then I used phrases in my tags like "bandana bib," "handkerchief bib," "baby bandana bib," etc. In order to use more meaningful tags, I opened a second window/tab and used the search bar to begin typing a search term I thought I might use. When you begin typing, the most popular search terms come up, so I made sure to use the ones that applied. Then I made sure that each listing (only 2), was different, especially at the beginning of the item description- no copy and pasting. That's it I suppose! Good luck to you! You've got some nice jewelry!