@Morning - I totally agree! I think it was a good movie, but not as an adaptation since, as you mentioned, I really didn't feel like it was "Holmes" I was looking at, but instead some sort of edgy hybrid.
And I haven't seen the mini-series... I will have to check it out! My husband and I are just finishing up a SciFi series, but I think I've had enough of futuristic 'doom and gloom' for a while. :) Holmes sounds like just the thing!
Oh, and on the note of books turned into TV series... has anyone watched the TV show "Merlin?" Someone was telling me it was really good, and I love Arthurian myth, but I was wondering if anyone here had seen it/enjoyed it...