Nichole- Try some of these titles and see if you get any better traffic to the shop:
Current title-
Peppermint Cream Body Lotion with Cocoa Butter and Sweet Almond Oil
Suggested title-
Vitamin E Body Lotion, Cocoa Butter and Almond Oil Moisturizer, Peppermint Fragrance
**********************************************************************************
Current title-
Apple Cider Soap
Suggested title-
olive oil and shea butter soap, cold processed moisturizing soap, apple cinnamon scent
Hope this gives you a small idea of how to write titles.
-pat